As a Houston hair stylist, one of the most common questions I hear is: "Should I get balayage or highlights?" Both techniques can transform your look, but they offer different aesthetics, maintenance requirements, and experiences. In this comprehensive guide, I'll break down everything you need to know to make the right choice for your hair.
In this article:
What is Balayage?
Balayage (pronounced bah-lee-ahzh) comes from the French word meaning "to sweep" or "to paint." This hand-painting technique creates a soft, natural-looking highlight effect with less noticeable regrowth lines.
The Balayage Process:
As a Goldwell Master Colorist, I apply lightener by hand in a sweeping motion, focusing more color on the mid-lengths and ends while keeping the application lighter at the roots. The hair is then typically wrapped in plastic wrap or left in the open air (rather than using foils) to process.
Balayage Pros:
- Creates a sun-kissed, natural-looking dimension
- Grows out more naturally with less obvious regrowth
- Typically requires less frequent touch-ups (every 3-4 months)
- Less damaging to hair as it usually uses less lightener
- Customizable to complement your face shape and skin tone
Balayage Cons:
- Not ideal for achieving a uniform, all-over lightened look
- Takes longer to apply (approximately 3 hours at our Houston salon)
- May require multiple sessions to achieve very light blonde on dark hair
- Typically costs more than traditional highlights
What are Traditional Highlights?
Traditional highlights use foil to separate strands of hair that are then lightened. This technique creates a more uniform, structured pattern of lightness throughout the hair.
The Highlighting Process:
When I apply foil highlights at our Vintage Park salon, I use a technique where small sections of hair are weaved out, painted with lightener, and wrapped in foil. The foil generates heat, allowing for a more effective lightening process.
Highlights Pros:
- Creates a more consistent, uniform brightening effect
- Can achieve greater lightness in a single session
- Works well for adding brightness around the face
- Excellent for fine hair that needs the appearance of volume
Highlights Cons:
- More noticeable regrowth line as hair grows out
- Requires more frequent touch-ups (typically every 6-8 weeks)
- Can potentially cause more damage if done too frequently
- Less customizable placement than hand-painted techniques
Key Differences Between Balayage and Highlights
| Feature | Balayage | Highlights |
|---|---|---|
| Application | Hand-painted, freehand technique | Sectioned with foils |
| Appearance | Soft, graduated, natural-looking | More uniform, structured brightness |
| Grow-out | Subtle, blended regrowth | More noticeable regrowth line |
| Processing | Open-air or plastic wrap | Foil to generate heat |
| Time in salon | 2.5-3 hours (at Kaizen Hair Studio) | 1.5-2.5 hours (at Kaizen Hair Studio) |
Here in Houston, I find that my clients with active lifestyles often prefer balayage for its lower maintenance requirements, while those who love a brighter, more consistent look typically opt for traditional highlights.
Which Lasts Longer?
When it comes to longevity, balayage generally has the edge:
Balayage Longevity:
Because balayage creates a graduated effect with softer regrowth lines, it can typically go 3-4 months between touch-ups. The natural-looking dimension means that as your hair grows, the transition between your natural color and the lightened sections remains relatively seamless.
Highlights Longevity:
Traditional highlights usually require maintenance every 6-8 weeks as the regrowth becomes more noticeable. The distinct line of demarcation between your natural hair color and the highlighted strands becomes increasingly visible as your hair grows.
Stylist Tip:
To extend the life of both balayage and highlights, I recommend using professional-grade, color-safe products like our Goldwell and Oribe lines. These products help maintain your color's vibrancy while protecting against the harsh Houston humidity.
Maintenance Requirements
Understanding the upkeep for each technique is crucial for making your decision:
Balayage Maintenance:
- Salon visits: Every 3-4 months for touch-ups
- At-home care: Purple shampoo 1-2 times weekly to combat brassiness (especially important in Houston's climate)
- Treatments: Monthly deep conditioning treatments to maintain hair health
- Products: Color-safe shampoo and conditioner, heat protectant
Highlights Maintenance:
- Salon visits: Every 6-8 weeks for root touch-ups
- At-home care: Purple shampoo 1-2 times weekly for blonde highlights
- Treatments: Bi-weekly deep conditioning to combat potential damage
- Products: Color-safe shampoo and conditioner, bond-building treatments
Which is Best for Your Hair Type?
Hair type plays a significant role in determining which technique will give you the best results:
Balayage works best for:
- Medium to thick hair - The technique shows up beautifully on more substantial hair types
- Wavy or curly textures - The free-form application complements natural movement
- Virgin hair or natural brunettes - Creates beautiful dimension without dramatic change
- Those wanting low-maintenance color - Perfect for busy Houston professionals
Highlights work best for:
- Fine or thin hair - Creates the illusion of volume and thickness
- Straight hair - The precision placement is more visible on sleek styles
- Gray coverage - Can be more effective at blending gray hair
- Those wanting significant lightening - Achieves brighter results in fewer sessions
Cost Comparison
At Kaizen Hair Studio in Houston's Vintage Park, our pricing reflects the time, expertise, and product usage required for each service:
Balayage
Starting at $190
Approximately 3 hours
Includes consultation, application, toner, and blow dry/style
Additional costs may apply for very long or thick hair
Highlights
Starting at $160
Approximately 2 hours 15 minutes
Includes consultation, application, toner, and blow dry/style
Partial highlights available starting at $100
When considering the overall investment, remember that balayage typically requires fewer appointments per year, which can make it more economical in the long run despite the higher initial cost.
Which Should You Choose?
The best choice between balayage and highlights depends on your lifestyle, maintenance preferences, and desired outcome:
Choose balayage if you:
- Prefer a natural, sun-kissed look
- Want low-maintenance color that grows out gracefully
- Have medium to thick, wavy or curly hair
- Don't mind a slightly higher initial investment
- Value a customized, face-framing effect
Choose highlights if you:
- Want a more uniform, brighter overall look
- Have fine hair that needs a volume boost
- Don't mind more frequent touch-ups
- Prefer a more structured, classic appearance
- Need effective gray blending
As a Houston hair stylist specializing in blonde techniques, I often recommend a combination approach for many of my clients. By incorporating both techniques—foil highlights around the face and crown for brightness, with balayage through the mid-lengths and ends for dimension—we can create a truly customized look that maximizes the benefits of both methods.
The best way to determine the right technique for you is through a professional consultation. At Kaizen Hair Studio, all our color services include a thorough consultation where we assess your hair type, lifestyle, and goals to recommend the perfect approach.
Ready to Transform Your Look?
Book your color consultation today and discover whether balayage, highlights, or a custom combination is right for you.
Book Instantly OnlineHave questions? Call us at (832) 819-2156 or visit our FAQ page.
Comments
We'd love to hear your thoughts! Slide into our DMs or comment at kaizenhairhtx